They are not confirmed as applicable to the TCG until they have been officially published by Konami. Retrieved 3 February Rules posted online will be limited to super-complicated and really weird situations.
Imagine going down to a dozen pages of card rules, instead of a thousand. It could happen. Namespaces Card Rulings Discussion. To give an analogy, if I'm a race car driver and I'm running in a race where it isn't long enough to require a pitstop, if I suddenly pull into the pit without notifying my crew, I can't be upset or hold them responsable for not being ready. We haven't planned for it, the mode of operation was to assume I wouldn't need to make a pit stop, now I'm going to hold them accountable for not being ready?
In the same manner, it's unfair for you and I to have forgone proceedureal fomalities of notification of actions, then for me to hold YOU accountable when I want to activate an effect that you have no knowledge of. So, both of us having forgone proper proceedure, it's my responsability to notify you of my intentions before they become an issue or at least ask you to begin to observe proper proceedure because "I" am the one who suddenly wants to break the typical mode of operations of the match as it has been played thus far.
It is the mindset of the UD Judge Manager that he does not want player manipulating lack of communication into an unfair advantage. The above scenario is a good example of that. KDE may come out with their own direction on such issues. I'll be interested to see KDE's tournament policy and penalty guidelines. To my knowledge they don't have such documents for the game of Yugioh at this time. If I'm mistaken by all means someone please point me toward them.
One of the things that Mr. Charsky and some of the L3 judges were working on as time allowed before the UD vs. KDE issue was a section to add to the policy statements regarding communications.
What that amounted to was what is a legal bluff, what is not and what information a player was required to give and what they are not, and what questions a player is required to answer honestly or not reply at all when asked by their opponent. A couple of years ago I don't believe a communications policy was a needed one. I believe though the game has evolved to a level of competitiveness that one now is indeed needed.
MTG went through the same thing and saw that need filling it. At first glance this would appear an easy task Communication is a highly complex subject to begin with, as it relates to a competitive game it becomes even more so. As far as losing the punch of the intended card Threatening Roar when players aren't observing proper play proceedure.
That is remedied fairly easily with a random bluff or two early on. If I say set Torrential Tribute, end my turn, and during your draw say, "Please let me know when you enter your battle phase" The other option if you don't think any of that cuts the butter and you're still worried about how it will be ruled Some players try to gain any advantage they can by hook or crook of course.
Taking advantage of "accepted" shortcuts and then manipulating them by saying, "Well my opponent didn't follow the rules and mechanics of the game! If a player knowingly tries to gain an unfair advantage or potential unfair advantage by twisting a scenario around, what does that make it?
Unsporting Conduct-Cheating Disqualification. Not taking away anything from Curtis. I think he was the hardest working man in ygo UDE.
He was amazing at giving us rapid answers to card rulings. But for some player management stuff, it seemed like he had to be kind of vague, unless he got a direct confirmation from konami. The most important thing in these situations is consistency. Consistency allows players to take more responsibility, because they know whats coming if they dont adhere to proper gameplay etiquette. The whole "I attack with all my monsters" vs opponent Gorz in hand is still being ruled very differently from place to place.
The reason that you didn't see Curtis address such issues is because this isn't a rulings issue, rather, it's a player management issue. For issues such as what I've spoken about the place to ask questions would have been the UD Player Management forum with the UD Judge Manager Alex Charsky kept an eye on and would pipe in when the unknown came about.
PM was controled by UD. If I'm incorrect and I may very well be by all means please point me to it. As far as consistency, that will always be difficult with a judge pool that is a volunteer group. You're always going to have judges with widely varying degrees of both RK knowledge and PM knowledge. This is why Mr.
Charsky lining up the HJs for those events. Charsky knew his judges well and who he was confident could handle widely varying and difficult scenarios.
This is also why it's so important that players understand their right to appeal a ruling to the HJ and why you'll hear a HJ go over that information at each and every premier event Yeah, I know you get tired of hearing it and think it's a waste of time.
You'd be suprised how many people don't know or claim they didn't know they could appeal. They were always public knowledge and posted on their website. Players need to take responsability to at least be reasonably familiar with these documents if they wish to participate in premier tournaments, a player is wise to do so. KDE doesn't have a history of open communication, hopefully they'll be changing that mode of operation in North America as they take over.
It's going to take some time to rebuild the judge pool after the take over. The design is also emblazoned with a term all booklovers can all relate to: 'abibliophobia uh-bib-li-uh-fo-bee-yuh.
The fear of running out of things to read'. Maia has won hundreds of pounds worth of National Book Tokens for herself and her school — just think of all those beautiful new books! View all six winners and runners-up. Tamara selected five questions out of hundreds sent in! Read now. Research shows that children are more likely to finish a book when they're able to choose it themselves.
Give a child a gift beyond words with a National Book Token — they'll love our fun designs by World Book Day illustrator Rob Biddulph, or choose one of our past competition winners' designs! National Book Tokens can be spent in hundreds of bookshops and online. Buy now. We use cookies to make our website work, analyse traffic to improve its performance, and tailor our advertisements to you.
0コメント